Shine Urges Community to Make Submissions on Discussion Paper

Attorney-General and Minister for Justice Kerry Shine has urged interested people to make a submission to the Queensland Law Reform Commission’s discussion paper, A Review of the Defence of Provocation.

The Commission has today released its second discussion paper as part of its review of the excuse of accident and the defence of provocation.

“The QLRC was commissioned to undertake this important work after my department carried out some preliminary work in this area in response to community concern after a number of court decisions where accident and provocation were relied upon,” Mr Shine said.

“Like the QLRC’s earlier discussion paper on the defence of accident, this discussion will explore issues which were raised by stakeholders responding to the Government’s discussion paper on the issue and it is right that the QLRC seeks further input on these important matters.”

Mr Shine said the defence of provocation has been an important part of our criminal law for centuries.

“Any change to the law requires careful consideration. That is why the Government referred this matter to the Queensland Law Reform Commission, which is best placed to give it the consideration it deserves.

“An audit of all homicide cases over the past five years did not disclose any undue reliance on these defences.

“We reviewed 80 murder trials and 20 manslaughter trials and what we found was that there were very few occasions where either accident or provocation were the only defences to be considered by the jury.

“On most occasions juries had other defences to consider in addition to accident or provocation.”

“It’s clear these new issues need to be carefully considered before any decision is made to change the law. This discussion paper gives everyone with an interest in law reform an opportunity to submit their views for consideration.”


Media Contact: Troy Davies 3239 6400 or 0488 799 273